Woman Finds Shocking Discovery in Neighbor's Home: EMT Kelly Levenson Murder Case
On March 30, 2024, authorities responded to a distressing call about a possible death at the residence of Kelly Levenson, a 44-year-old EMT. Upon arrival, officers found the door locked and had to force entry, discovering Kelly's body face down in the living room with blood pooled around her head. The evidence immediately suggested foul play, as a spent .45 caliber shell casing was found in the bathroom threshold, and the position of the wound to the back of her head ruled out suicide.
The investigation quickly shifted focus from a possible robbery to someone close to the victim. Despite finding $3,000 in cash untouched, investigators noted male clothing items and other signs suggesting someone had been living with Kelly. A black duffel bag with the initials "WLT" became a key piece of evidence, eventually leading detectives to William "Bill" Tally, a 52-year-old married man who was allegedly in a relationship with Kelly. Friends later revealed concerns about Tally's controlling behavior and how Kelly had become increasingly isolated.
Key Takeaways
Kelly Levenson, a 44-year-old EMT, was found murdered in her home with evidence pointing to homicide rather than suicide or robbery.
Evidence including male clothing, an untouched cash sum, and a duffel bag with "WLT" initials shifted the investigation toward someone close to the victim.
William "Bill" Tally, a married 52-year-old described as controlling by friends, became the primary person of interest in Kelly's murder.
Emergency Response
Neighbor's 911 Call
A concerned neighbor contacted emergency services after suspecting someone might be dead inside a neighboring house. The caller specifically mentioned 44-year-old Kelly Levenson, believing she might have been shot, which immediately triggered an urgent response from law enforcement.
Upon arrival at the residence, officers found the door locked. Among the responding officers was Deputy Brown, who noted the presence of a dog inside the home. The officers had to force entry into the locked house, proceeding with caution and weapons drawn as they methodically searched the premises for potential threats.
The officers discovered Kelly's body lying face down in the living room with blood pooling around her head. She was already deceased upon their arrival. Based on the position of the body and evidence at the scene, investigators immediately determined this was not a self-inflicted injury. The victim was found with her hands underneath her body, and blood spatter was visible on the wall near where her head would have been if she had been standing.
A key piece of evidence was found in the threshold of the bathroom - a .45 caliber Winchester brand shell casing. The positioning of this casing, combined with the apparent injury to the back of the victim's head, strongly indicated foul play rather than suicide.
Crime Scene Examination
First Responders Enter Property
Officers responded to an alarming call about a possible shooting at Kelly Levenson's residence. Upon arrival, they found the door locked and had to force entry, proceeding cautiously with weapons drawn. Inside, they discovered a distressing scene: 44-year-old Kelly Levenson lying face down on the living room floor with blood pooling around her head. She had already passed away by the time they arrived.
The body position immediately raised suspicions. Kelly was lying on her stomach with her hands underneath her body. Blood spatter marked the wall at head height, indicating where she had been standing when shot. A spent .45 caliber Winchester Plus P shell casing was found in the bathroom doorway threshold, clearly suggesting this was not self-inflicted.
The positioning of both the injury to the back of her head and the location of the shell casing confirmed to investigators they were dealing with a homicide. Officers recognized Kelly as a local EMT worker with whom many of them had professional interactions.
Physical Evidence Collection
The house presented a chaotic scene with scattered items and clothing, potentially indicating a struggle. Investigators initially considered a robbery gone wrong but quickly revised this theory when they found an untouched bank envelope containing approximately $3,000 in cash.
Key evidence collected included:
A blood-stained cell phone found underneath the victim
A second cell phone charging in the bedroom
Male clothing items throughout the residence
A large vodka bottle (preserved for potential DNA)
A black duffel bag with "WLT" initials near the victim
Several signs pointed to a male presence in the home: men's clothing, an upraised toilet seat, and personal items suggesting someone regularly stayed there. The crime scene technicians meticulously photographed and collected all potential evidence for further analysis.
The victim's family members, mother Wilma and brother Gary, were devastated by the news. A neighbor provided valuable information about seeing Kelly with a white-haired boyfriend days before the murder. When questioned, Kelly's mother identified a 52-year-old man named William "Bill" Tally as a close friend of her daughter's, though she didn't believe they were romantically involved.
Friends later confirmed Kelly had been in a relationship with the married Tally, who was significantly older. They noted concerning patterns of controlling behavior and how Kelly had become increasingly isolated from her social circle during their relationship.
Victim Profile
Kelly Levenson's Life and Professional Journey
Kelly Levenson was a 44-year-old advanced emergency medical technician employed by Care Ambulance. Originally from Columbus, she earned an associate's degree in criminal justice from Columbus State University before pursuing her EMT training. Many local officers were familiar with Kelly through her work as a paramedic. She maintained close relationships with her family members, particularly her mother Wilma and brother Gary, as well as her friends and her dog.
Family's Response to the Tragedy
When Kelly's mother Wilma and brother Gary learned about her murder, they were devastated. Their only wish following this tragic event was to see justice served for Kelly. Though Wilma initially believed Kelly wasn't dating anyone, she mentioned Kelly's close friendship with 52-year-old William "Bill" Tally, describing him as a trustworthy individual who had protected Kelly during difficult times. Wilma firmly believed Tally could never harm her daughter. Meanwhile, a neighbor who had seen Kelly with a white-haired man identified as her boyfriend provided additional insight into Kelly's personal life that her family may not have been fully aware of.
Friends later confirmed Kelly had been in a relationship with Tally, who was married but reportedly planning to divorce his wife. According to one friend, Kelly appeared happy in the relationship initially, but something seemed amiss as Kelly became increasingly secretive and isolated from her social circle, suggesting potentially controlling behavior from her partner.
Focus Shifts to Individuals Under Investigation
Suspicious Activities and Witness Statements
The investigation gained momentum when a neighbor reported concerning activity at Kelly Levenson's residence. The witness described seeing a small car parked at the property days before the murder. She observed a white-haired man accompanied by a woman who had keys to the home. Initially concerned about a potential break-in, the neighbor was later informed by her nephew that the visitors were likely Kelly and her boyfriend.
This neighborhood observation became significant as detectives expanded their search for information about Kelly's personal relationships. When questioned, Kelly's mother Wilma stated her daughter wasn't dating anyone but mentioned a close friendship with 52-year-old William "Bill" Tally, describing him as trustworthy and protective of Kelly.
Investigators noted several indicators of male presence in Kelly's home:
Men's clothing items scattered throughout the residence
Upright toilet seat in the bathroom
Personal items suggesting regular male visits
Connecting WLT to the Crime Scene
A critical discovery at the crime scene was a black duffel bag bearing the initials "WLT" found near Kelly's body. These initials immediately drew investigators' attention, especially after learning about William "Bill" Tally from family interviews. The matching initials transformed Tally from a peripheral figure to a primary person of interest.
Further interviews with Kelly's friends revealed crucial information:
Kelly was indeed in a relationship with Tally
Tally was married but reportedly planning to divorce his wife
The relationship appeared secretive and isolated Kelly from friends
Friends noted concerning behavioral changes in Kelly
One friend expressed particular concern about Kelly's communication patterns: "She wasn't telling us the stuff she would normally tell us." This friend noted that Kelly had become increasingly reserved about her relationship details and displayed uncharacteristic secrecy.
Additionally, the friend described potentially controlling behaviors in the relationship. Kelly, previously open with friends, had grown distant and withdrawn. This behavioral shift, combined with the physical evidence at the crime scene, strengthened investigators' focus on Tally as they continued building their case.
Unraveling Relationships
William "Bill" Tally's Connection to Kelly
Kelly Levenson, the 44-year-old EMT worker found deceased in her home, maintained what appeared to be a complex relationship with William "Bill" Tally. Despite Kelly's mother describing Tally as merely a close friend and trustworthy protector, evidence suggested a more intimate connection. The black duffel bag found at the crime scene bearing the initials "WLT" provided investigators with their first tangible link to Tally.
Friends of Kelly eventually confirmed she was indeed involved romantically with the 52-year-old Tally, who was married at the time. According to these accounts, Tally had reportedly been planning to leave his wife and finalize a divorce. The relationship had been kept relatively private, with Kelly becoming increasingly reserved about sharing details with even her closest friends.
Key relationship indicators found at the scene:
Male clothing items discovered in Kelly's home
Evidence of a male regularly staying at or visiting the residence
The distinctive black duffel bag with "WLT" initials
Inner Circle Insights and Concerns
Those close to Kelly noticed concerning patterns in her relationship with Tally. One friend expressed growing unease about how Kelly had become increasingly secretive about her relationship. "In the beginning I was happy for her, but quickly I was like something's not right," the friend stated during interviews with investigators. This withdrawal from her normal social patterns raised red flags among her inner circle.
Multiple accounts pointed to Tally's potentially controlling behavior. Friends noticed Kelly had become isolated from her social network, a common warning sign in unhealthy relationships. One friend specifically questioned whether Tally was restricting Kelly's communication with others, noting how uncharacteristic her silence had become.
A neighbor had spotted Kelly with a white-haired man at her brother Gary's residence days before the murder. This sighting corroborated the existence of a relationship that Kelly appeared to be keeping somewhat hidden from portions of her family and social circle.
Concerning behaviors noted by friends:
Kelly's unusual reluctance to discuss relationship details
Decreasing contact with previously close friends
Apparent isolation from her support network
Secretive nature of the relationship despite its seriousness
