8 True Crime Documentaries Set in Colorado That Will Keep You Up at Night
Uncover Chilling Stories
For those who find themselves endlessly fascinated by the world of true crime, Colorado’s rich and often dark history offers a treasure trove of riveting documentary content. The state’s breathtaking landscapes serve as a stark contrast to the chilling tales of mystery, crime, and tragedy that have unfolded within its borders.
What are the must-watch true crime documentaries set in Colorado that promise to keep viewers on edge? From infamous homicides to perplexing disappearances, these documentaries offer a deep dive into the complexities and often shocking realities of crime in the Centennial State. Whether you are a seasoned true crime enthusiast or just beginning to explore the genre, these films will surely captivate and disturb.
1) Killer Women with Piers Morgan: The Case of Jennifer Reali (2016)
Jennifer Reali, a convicted murderer, became infamous for her role in a crime driven by what many saw as a "Fatal Attraction" scenario.
Reali spent nearly 30 years in prison for the killing of her lover's wife in 1990. This high-profile case drew comparisons to the 1987 film "Fatal Attraction," where an affair ends in deadly consequences.
Piers Morgan interviews Reali in the documentary "Killer Women," attempting to understand her motives and psychological state during the time of the murder. Morgan's approach brings an intense and personal perspective to this tragic story.
Reali's case is one of five presented in the series, highlighting the different backgrounds and stories of female murderers. This documentary provides a glimpse into the mindset of women who commit such crimes and the factors that may drive them.
For more information, visit the IMDB page.
2) American Monster: Second Chance featuring Tom Luther (2020)
"American Monster: Second Chance" tells the gripping story of Joy and Fred, high school sweethearts whose lives are dramatically altered by a tragic work accident. Fred's trauma leads to a series of events that strain their relationship.
As Joy seeks new beginnings, she faces unexpected challenges. The episode uncovers the emotional turmoil and unforeseen consequences she encounters.
This particular installment offers a detailed perspective on personal tragedy and its far-reaching effects. It skillfully weaves together true crime elements with emotional depth, making it compelling viewing for enthusiasts of the genre.
For more details, visit the IMDb page on American Monster: Second Chance.
3) The Killing Season: The Long Island Serial Killer in Colorado
"The Killing Season" (2016) delves into one of the most perplexing unsolved serial killer cases: the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK). Documentarians Joshua Zeman and Rachel Mills investigate the discovery of ten sex workers' bodies on Gilgo Beach, Long Island.
Even though the series mainly focuses on this New York case, the investigation touches several other states. This includes potential connections and insights related to Colorado's own unsolved cases. The broadened scope of "The Killing Season" reflects the complexity and interconnections of serial crimes across different regions.
For those interested in exploring the full extent of the series, detailed information and further watching options are available here.
4) The Family I Had: The Case of the Kenyon Family Murders (2017)
The documentary "The Family I Had" explores the heartbreaking and tragic case of the Kenyon family murders. Carlye Rubin and Katie Green team up to present a case that started as a juvenile justice system inquiry.
During production, the filmmakers' focus shifted dramatically when they discovered the story of a young boy named Paris Bennett, who at the age of 13, was convicted of brutally murdering his younger sister.
The documentary depends deeply on personal narratives, featuring interviews with Bennett, his mother Charity Lee, and other family members. Their accounts provide a raw and harrowing insight into the impact of the crime on the family.
Rubin and Green's work shines a light on the complexities of the justice system, mental health issues, and the long-lasting effects of violence within families. The film takes an intimate and unsettling look at one family's unimaginable tragedy.
Watch "The Family I Had" to gain a deeper understanding of this haunting case and the emotional and legal intricacies involved. Learn more about this powerful documentary here.
5) Mindhunter: The Catcher in the Woods Episode
In the hit Netflix series "Mindhunter," the episode known as "The Catcher in the Woods" offers a fascinating glimpse into the Behavioral Science Unit's investigations.
Set against the backdrop of the eerie forests of Colorado, this episode features FBI agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench as they seek to understand the mind of a unique killer operating in the area.
The episode draws from real-life cases and interviews with convicted murderers, combining them with dramatized elements to create a gripping narrative.
Through meticulous profiling and intense questioning, the agents edge closer to uncovering the truth behind the unsettling events.
Fans of true crime will appreciate the detailed depiction of the psychological tactics used by the FBI to track and apprehend the perpetrator.
For more information about "Mindhunter" on Netflix, visit the official IMDb page (2017).
6) Most Evil: Colorado’s Covenant for Murder (2024)
Most Evil: Colorado’s Covenant for Murder delves into the chilling events of a secluded religious cult in the Rocky Mountains.
This documentary explores the dark side of faith in the picturesque town of Sangre de Cristo. Followers, captivated by a charismatic leader, fell into a spiraling web of manipulation and violent rituals.
The series examines the lives disrupted and lost due to the cult’s sinister practices. Interviews with survivors and law enforcement provide a gripping narrative of control and bloodshed.
The stark contrast between the serene Colorado landscape and the evil acts committed within this covenant adds to the haunting atmosphere of the documentary.
7) Murder Mountain: The Deadly Sins Episode (2018)
Murder Mountain, also known as Murder Mountain: Welcome to Humboldt County, delves into the dark underbelly of Northern California's marijuana industry.
This true crime documentary series first aired on Fusion TV before gaining popularity on Netflix in late December 2018.
The series uncovers a wave of disappearances and unsolved murders among marijuana growers in Humboldt County.
The episode "The Deadly Sins" explores the complexities and dangers that come with the territory.
It examines the lives of the people drawn to the area in search of quick money through cannabis cultivation.
Local law enforcement struggles to maintain order amidst the lawlessness and secrecy of the region.
The documentary provides a gripping look into the darker side of the marijuana industry and the human cost involved.
For more information about Murder Mountain, visit IMDb.
8) Serial Killer Earth: Colorado Climbing Murders
"Serial Killer Earth: Colorado Climbing Murders" (2013) delves into the unsettling intersection of natural landscapes and human violence. This docuseries episode is part of the larger "Serial Killer Earth" franchise, which examines how environmental factors contribute to heinous crimes.
The episode focuses on several murders that occurred in Colorado's mountainous regions.
The show covers the chilling case of Ted Bundy, who notoriously targeted victims in Colorado. His crimes in the state included the abduction and murder of Caryn Eileen Campbell in Snowmass Village.
Bundy's ability to navigate the rugged terrain added a chilling element to his already terrifying modus operandi.
Viewers are also introduced to other harrowing incidents, such as unsolved murders where the wilderness played a crucial role in the crimes and investigations. The documentary interviews experts and law enforcement officers who recount their experiences and challenges faced during these baffling cases.
Film buffs and true crime aficionados can find more about "Serial Killer Earth: Colorado Climbing Murders" on IMDb.
The Rise of True Crime Interest
The surge in popularity of true crime content, particularly documentaries, can be attributed to both its psychological appeal and its impact on contemporary culture. Understanding these elements provides insights into why audiences are magnetically drawn to these gripping narratives.
Psychological Appeal
The psychological allure of true crime documentaries lies in the natural human curiosity about the darker sides of human behavior. They tap into a primal fascination with the unknown and the macabre.
Many people experience a heightened sense of empathy and moral engagement when following these stories. The complexity of crime, combined with the process of solving it, encourages viewers to play detective from their living rooms, engaging their critical thinking skills.
True crime narratives often delve into the minds of criminals and law enforcement, offering an educational glimpse into psychological profiles and investigative techniques. This educational aspect can be both captivating and, at times, unsettling, which contributes to its strong pull on viewers.
Cultural Impact
True crime content has left an indelible mark on popular culture. With the advent of streaming platforms, these documentaries have become more accessible than ever, reaching a global audience and spawning numerous online discussions and fandoms.
Documentaries such as Making a Murderer have not only captured widespread viewer attention but have also sparked debates about legal and criminal justice systems. These discussions often lead to increased awareness and, in some cases, activism or advocacy for changes in policy and practice.
The genre's influence extends beyond entertainment. It often intersects with journalism, prompting a closer examination of societal issues such as racial injustice, systemic corruption, and the adequacy of the legal system. This intersection fosters a more informed and critically engaged audience.
Key Cases and Their Impact
Several true crime documentaries have highlighted notable cases in Colorado, shedding light on the heinous acts committed and their profound effects on local communities. The following sections will delve into some of these key cases and their influence.
Discussion of Notorious Crimes
Colorado has been the setting for numerous high-profile crimes featured in documentaries. One prominent case is the Watts family murders. In 2018, Chris Watts confessed to killing his pregnant wife and two young daughters. This horrific crime was the focus of the documentary American Murder: The Family Next Door, revealing disturbing details about the case and Watts' double life.
Another significant case is the JonBenét Ramsey murder. The six-year-old beauty queen was found dead in her Boulder home in 1996, and despite intense media coverage and numerous theories, the case remains unsolved. Documentaries like Casting JonBenét have examined various aspects of the crime, including the family's controversial media appearances and the police's handling of the investigation.
Influence on Local Communities
These notorious crimes have left deep scars on the affected communities. The Watts murders caused ripples of fear and grief in Frederick, Colorado, a small town left grappling with the loss and betrayal by one of their own. Memorials and community vigils highlighted the collective sorrow and the struggle to find justice.
In Boulder, the JonBenét Ramsey case triggered widespread anxiety and mistrust. The town became a media circus, with intense scrutiny on both the family and the local law enforcement. This has led to ongoing debates about police procedures and media ethics, impacting how future cases are approached and handled by the authorities.
Communities often find themselves altered by the trauma and attention brought by such crimes, leading to long-lasting changes in their social fabric and sense of security.
