10 Documentaries That Examine the Role of Film Critics in Shaping Public Opinion

Unveiling Influence

Documentaries often uncover powerful narratives that illuminate various facets of society and culture. Among these, films focusing on the role of critics in shaping public opinion stand out by exploring the dynamics between cinematic art, societal perspectives, and media influence.

These documentaries provide an in-depth look at how film critics can sway audience perceptions and contribute to the broader discourse on cinema. Through interviews, archival footage, and expert analysis, these films reveal the impact of film criticism on different aspects of life, demonstrating its significance in the cultural landscape.

1) Life Itself - Roger Ebert (2014)

"Life Itself" offers an in-depth look into the life and career of Roger Ebert, one of the most influential film critics of all time. Directed by Steve James, the documentary is based on Ebert's own memoir and captures the essence of his contributions to film criticism.

The film features graphic scenes from Ebert's battle with cancer, showcasing his resilience and determination. These moments provide a personal glimpse into his life, highlighting not just his professional achievements but also his human struggles.

The documentary explores various facets of Ebert's life, including his background as a newsman, his rise to fame, and his impact on popular culture. It reveals how his reviews could make or break a film's success, showcasing his immense influence.

"Life Itself" is also a tribute to Ebert's legacy, detailing the ways his work shaped public opinion about films. It emphasizes his role in bringing thoughtful, articulate film criticism to a mass audience.

More information about "Life Itself" can be found on IMDB.

2) What the Flick?! - Christy Lemire

"What the Flick?!" is a film review series hosted by notable critics including Christy Lemire, Alonso Duralde, Ben Mankiewicz, and Matt Atchity.

Christy Lemire, a prominent film critic, brings her extensive knowledge and clear insights to the show.

The series, which aired from 2010 to 2018, is known for its honest and in-depth reviews.

These critics analyze a wide range of films, from blockbusters to independent releases, helping to shape public opinion through their candid discussions.

Christy Lemire's expertise in film criticism is evident in her evaluations, often highlighting aspects of performance, direction, and screenplay.

By providing informed perspectives, she and her co-hosts at "What the Flick?!" offer viewers a deeper appreciation of cinema.

For more information on "What the Flick?!", visit its IMDb page.

3) For the Love of Movies - Gerald Peary (2009)

Directed by Gerald Peary, "For the Love of Movies: The Story of American Film Criticism" traverses a century of American film criticism.

The documentary includes interviews with prominent critics like Roger Ebert and A.O. Scott. Peary brings a unique perspective as a long-time critic himself and former Acting Curator of the Harvard Film Archive.

The film showcases archival footage, historic photographs, and extensive commentary. Notable segments cover the evolution of film criticism from print to digital platforms.

Key participants such as Patricia Clarkson and Elvis Mitchell add depth to the documentary. Peary's film is essential viewing for those interested in the impact of film critics on public perception.

Learn more about "For the Love of Movies: The Story of American Film Criticism" here.

4) Film Critic - Mark Kermode

Mark Kermode is one of the most distinguished film critics in the UK. Known for his insightful analysis and uncompromising opinions, he has become a trusted voice in the world of cinema.

Kermode is best known for his long-running BBC show, "Kermode and Mayo's Film Review," where he regularly discusses films from various genres and countries. His profound understanding of film history and cinematic techniques is evident in his critiques.

Kermode has also made significant contributions to documentary filmmaking. His series "Mark Kermode’s Secrets of Cinema" exemplifies his deep dive into the elements that make up different cinematic genres. Each episode breaks down the conventions and techniques that define genres such as horror, rom-coms, and more.

Additionally, Kermode has authored several books on film criticism. His works explore the impact of cinema on society and offer personal insights into the art of filmmaking. Through these publications, he has influenced both audiences and aspiring filmmakers.

For a broader understanding of Kermode’s impact, one can look to his extensive film recommendations. His list of “50 Films Every Film Fan Should Watch” showcases a mix of classic films and hidden gems, reflecting his diverse taste and in-depth knowledge of cinema.

Learn more about Mark Kermode's work and film recommendations on Wikipedia.

5) The Film Critic - Carlos Boyero

Carlos Boyero, one of Spanish cinema's most influential critics, has had a long and storied career. Over four decades, he has become known for his fearless and often controversial opinions on films and filmmakers.

Boyero's journey as a critic began with his first article over 40 years ago. Since then, his work has often placed him in the spotlight, making him both a respected and feared figure in the industry.

The 2022 documentary El crítico (The Critic), directed by Javier Morales Pérez and Juan Zavala, offers a detailed look into Boyero's life and career. The film features interviews with colleagues, editors, and filmmakers, painting a nuanced picture of his impact on Spanish cinema.

Through the documentary, viewers gain insight into the evolving landscape of film criticism in Spain and Boyero's role in shaping the dialogue around cinema.

For more information on El crítico (2022), visit IMDb.

6) Critic’s Choice - Leonard Maltin

Leonard Maltin is a renowned film critic, historian, and author who has significantly influenced the landscape of film criticism.

He is best known for "Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide," a reference work that has guided countless film enthusiasts and educators since its inception. Maltin also authored "Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide," which focuses on older films.

Maltin's insightful reviews appeared on television's "Entertainment Tonight" for thirty years, demonstrating his broad appeal and deep understanding of cinema.

In his career, Maltin has notably critiqued and analyzed numerous films, impacting the opinions of both casual moviegoers and serious film students.

One notable aspect of Maltin's legacy is his willingness to revisit and revise his opinions, acknowledging the evolving nature of film interpretation. For instance, his initial ratings for "Taxi Driver" and "Blade Runner" sparked discussions, exemplifying his influence.

In addition to his written work, Maltin's blog "Leonard Maltin's Movie Crazy" and podcast "Maltin on Movies" continue to engage audiences, reflecting his dedication to film criticism.

Learn more about Leonard Maltin here.

7) The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema - Slavoj Žižek (2006)

Slavoj Žižek's documentary, directed by Sophie Fiennes, explores the intricate relationship between cinema and psychoanalytic theory. Žižek, a Slovenian philosopher and psychoanalyst, takes viewers on a journey through various famous films, dissecting their hidden meanings and underlying psychoanalytic themes.

Žižek's engaging narrative style makes complex psychoanalytic concepts accessible. He often places himself within reconstructed scenes from the films he discusses, offering a unique visual and intellectual experience. This method helps to clarify the abstract ideas he presents.

Taking an in-depth look at cinema through the lens of psychoanalysis, Žižek examines how films communicate subconscious desires and fears. This documentary challenges viewers to rethink their perceptions of well-known movies and extends their understanding of film theory.

"The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema" is not just a critique of individual movies but an exploration of the entire medium. By analyzing key scenes and cinematic techniques, Žižek makes a compelling case for the deep psychological impact of cinema on its audience.

For more information on "The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema," visit IMDb.

8) Misery Loves Comedy - Kevin Pollak (2015)

"Misery Loves Comedy," directed by Kevin Pollak, explores the complex relationship between comedy and personal pain. The documentary features interviews with over fifty comedians, including Tom Hanks, Jimmy Fallon, and Amy Schumer.

Pollak examines whether misery is a necessary ingredient for comedy. The film delves into the comedic process and the backgrounds of these comedians, shedding light on their personal struggles and motivations.

Despite its broad scope, some critics felt that Pollak's inclusivity diluted the film's impact.

For more information, visit the IMDb page.

9) A Man from the Sky - Manohla Dargis

"A Man from the Sky" (2018) delves into the intricate world of film criticism through the eyes of renowned critic Manohla Dargis. Known for her incisive reviews and deep industry knowledge, Dargis provides an insightful look at the impact that critics have on shaping both public opinion and the film industry itself.

The film explores Dargis's career, highlighting her tenure at The Los Angeles Times and her influential role at The New York Times. Through a series of interviews and archival footage, viewers gain a deeper appreciation of her analytical approach to film and her thoughts on the evolving landscape of film criticism.

The documentary also touches upon the significance of festivals like Cannes and Sundance, where Dargis's opinions have often amplified or deflated the buzz surrounding films. Featuring interviews with directors and fellow critics, the film captures the ripple effect of her work in real-time.

"A Man from the Sky" combines personal anecdotes with professional insights, providing a well-rounded portrait of one of today's most respected film critics. For more details, visit IMDB or Wikipedia.

10) Future Critic - Wesley Morris

Wesley Morris stands as a distinguished voice in contemporary film criticism. As a critic at large for The New York Times, he examines the intersection of race and pop culture with an insightful lens.

His work often addresses the broader cultural implications of film, leveraging his position to challenge and reshape public perceptions.

Winning the Pulitzer Prize for Criticism in 2021, Morris was recognized for essays that explore how racial identity influences artistic expression. He is known for diving deep into the cultural narratives that films project and how they resonate with audiences.

Morris's thoughtful reviews contribute significantly to the understanding of film as a cultural artifact.

His career highlights the evolving role of critics in media. With a focus on not just the artistic quality of films but also their societal impact, he bridges the gap between pop culture and deeper societal issues.

Wesley Morris's contributions reflect the growing importance of diverse perspectives in criticism, enriching the discourse on both film and culture.

For more about Wesley Morris, check out his profile on The New York Times.

The Historical Influence of Film Critics

Film critics have significantly shaped public perception and understanding of cinema over the decades. Their role has evolved, reflecting changes in media, technology, and cultural values.

Early Film Criticism

In the early 20th century, film criticism began to emerge as an important cultural force. Newspapers and magazines featured reviews that helped guide audiences' movie choices. Critics like Pauline Kael and Andrew Sarris influenced the development of auteur theory, which emphasized a director's personal vision.

Their work often provided a deeper insight into the thematic and stylistic elements of films, helping the public to appreciate cinema as an art form rather than mere entertainment. This period laid the foundation for film criticism as a respected intellectual pursuit.

Evolution Over Decades

As cinema technology evolved, so did film criticism. The rise of television and the Internet transformed how critics reached their audience. Blogs, vlogs, and social media allowed for a more democratized form of criticism, where both professional and amateur reviewers could share their opinions widely.

The influence of film critics broadened, impacting not just arthouse circles but mainstream audiences as well. Contemporary critics continue to shape opinions, as showcased in platforms like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, demonstrating that the core role of film criticism in shaping public opinion remains robust and dynamic.

Film Critics' Impact on Public Opinion

Film critics play a substantial role in influencing how audiences perceive movies. Their reviews can significantly affect both individual opinions and broader cultural perceptions.

Shaping Perceptions

Film critics help shape perceptions by providing expert analysis and contextual understanding of films. They offer insights that might not be immediately obvious to general audiences.

Through their critiques, they encourage viewers to engage with films on a deeper level. This includes examining themes, symbolism, and directorial choices.

By drawing attention to specific aspects, such as an actor’s performance or a director’s unique style, critics help audiences appreciate the nuances of filmmaking. Well-respected critics, thus, become trusted voices that guide public conversation about a film’s merit and impact.

Box Office Influence

Critics' reviews can also directly impact a film’s commercial success. Positive critiques often boost ticket sales, drawing larger audiences to theaters.

Conversely, negative reviews can discourage viewers, affecting box office earnings. In some cases, even a single influential critic can sway public interest significantly.

Additionally, aggregated review scores on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic can elevate a film's status or contribute to its decline.

This commercial impact underscores the importance of critical reception, demonstrating how critics not only reflect but also shape public opinion through their assessments. Bold headlines in reviews and star ratings are examples of how critics' opinions are distilled into easily digestible forms for the audience.

Criticism in the Digital Age

The digital transformation has shifted the landscape of film criticism, introducing new platforms and voices that have democratized the space. Traditional critics now share the spotlight with a diverse array of online reviewers and social media influencers.

Rise of Online Reviews

Online reviews have provided a broad stage for film criticism. Blogs, specialized websites, and forums have empowered anyone with internet access to publish their thoughts.

This decentralization leads to a more diverse set of opinions. It allows niche films to find advocates, which was less feasible in the era of print-only media.

Professional critics still produce critiques, but they now compete with user reviews on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb. These sites aggregate user scores and professional reviews, influencing audience decisions.

With the proliferation of online spaces, film discourse has become instantaneous. Reviews and critiques appear almost immediately after a film's release, creating a dynamic and continuous conversation about cinema.

Social Media Dynamics

Social media has drastically altered the way film criticism is disseminated and consumed. Platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok enable real-time reactions and widespread discussion.

Influencers and content creators on these platforms can sway public opinion with a single post. Their reach often rivals or surpasses that of traditional media outlets.

Hashtags and trending topics can amplify certain reviews and create viral moments, impacting a film’s reputation. A poorly-received movie can become the subject of online ridicule quickly, while a beloved one can gain cult status.

The engagement-driven nature of social media also means that critiques are often brief and to-the-point, appealing to quick consumption habits. This brevity can sometimes simplify discussions that warrant deeper analysis.