Best Documentaries About the Amish
Insightful Films on a Unique Culture
The Amish community has long captivated audiences with its unique way of life, deeply rooted in tradition and religious values. Their simple, technology-free existence offers a stark contrast to modern society, which is why many documentary filmmakers have sought to explore and capture their world on screen. These films provide viewers with an intimate glimpse into the lives, struggles, and beliefs of the Amish, offering a rare perspective on a culture that is often misunderstood.
Discovering the best documentaries about the Amish can provide deeper insights into their faith, family dynamics, and the challenges they face in maintaining their customs. Through the lens of skilled filmmakers, these documentaries bring to light the personal stories of those who choose to stay and those who leave, shedding light on the complexities within the community.
1) The Amish: Shunned (2014)
"The Amish: Shunned" provides a compelling look into the lives of those who have left the Amish community. This 2014 documentary, produced by PBS's American Experience, follows seven individuals who face the emotional and social consequences of their decision to leave.
The film delves into the concept of shunning, a practice where those who leave are ostracized by family and community. Through intimate interviews and poignant storytelling, viewers gain insight into the hardship and hope experienced by those who chose a different path.
Detailed narratives illustrate the complexities of balancing personal freedom with the loss of familial connections. Each story contributes to a broader understanding of the costs and consequences associated with leaving the Amish way of life.
Find more information here.
2) Breaking the Silence: The Amish
"Breaking the Silence: The Amish" (2018) offers an honest portrayal of the Amish community's origins, culture, and challenges. This documentary series presents personal stories and interviews with former Amish individuals, church leaders, and historians.
The series emphasizes the experiences of Lester and Rebecca Graber, detailing their journey through salvation, excommunication, and eventual departure from the Amish church.
Audiences gain insight into the Amish way of life and the complexities individuals face when choosing to leave the community.
For more information, visit the IMDb page for Breaking the Silence: My Amish Story (2018).
3) The Amish: A People of Preservation (1975)
"The Amish: A People of Preservation" offers a unique look into the lifestyle and beliefs of the Amish community. Directed by John Ruth, a Mennonite historian, this film delves into the historical background and day-to-day life of the Amish.
This PBS documentary is noted for its sympathetic and respectful portrayal. By providing a window into the Amish mindset, viewers gain insight into why they maintain traditional ways. The visual elements of this film enhance its narrative, capturing the picturesque simplicity of Amish life.
John Ruth's approach brings a sense of authenticity to the storytelling. His background as a Mennonite historian allows for an informed perspective, which lends credibility to the documentary. The film succeeds in showcasing the cultural and religious beliefs that define the Amish community.
The documentary has been recognized for its quality and contribution to understanding the Amish. It continues to be a reference point for anyone interested in learning about this unique group. The historical context provided is invaluable, making it a must-watch for documentary enthusiasts.
For more on "The Amish: A People of Preservation," visit IMDb.
4) Amish: Out of Order (2012)
"Amish: Out of Order" is a compelling documentary series that premiered in 2012. It chronicles the lives of former Amish individuals as they adjust to the complexities of modern society. The series offers a candid view of their struggles and triumphs, shedding light on the realities they face after leaving their insular communities.
At the heart of the series is Mose Gingerich, an ex-Amish man, who guides and supports others navigating their new lives. His efforts to help former Amish individuals find their footing in the "English" world, while maintaining their values, are poignantly documented.
Set primarily in Columbia, Missouri, the series explores the profound emotional impact and cultural adjustments experienced by those who have left the Amish way of life. Viewers get an intimate look at the emotional toll and societal challenges they must overcome.
Each episode delves into personal stories, providing insight into the daily lives of ex-Amish individuals. The narrative highlights their ongoing internal conflicts and the support systems that emerge within their new community.
For more information, visit IMDb's page for "Amish: Out of Order".
5) The Witness: A Tale of the Amish
"The Witness: A Tale of the Amish (1985)" is widely regarded as one of the most well-known films centered on the Amish community.
The movie stars Harrison Ford as John Book, a detective who goes undercover in an Amish community to protect a young boy who witnessed a murder.
Directed by Peter Weir, this film shines a light on the clash between modern society and Amish traditions.
It showcases the peaceful, communal lifestyle of the Amish, juxtaposed against the violence and corruption of urban life.
The film's attention to detail and respectful portrayal of Amish culture earned it critical acclaim and an Oscar for Best Original Screenplay.
Its gripping narrative and strong performances make "The Witness" a compelling watch for anyone interested in the Amish way of life.
For more information, visit the IMDB page.
6) The Amish: How They Survive
"The Amish: How They Survive" (2010) explores the lives of the Amish people, who live largely isolated from the outside world. The documentary highlights their growth from 5,000 individuals in a few states to over 200,000 people across 25 states and one Canadian province.
The film delves into various aspects of Amish life, from their simple lifestyle and dress to their customs and community-oriented living. It provides a glimpse into how they maintain their traditions and values in a rapidly changing world.
The Amish community is known for rejecting many forms of modern technology such as electricity and automobiles but still using horse-drawn buggies. Their adherence to a set of rules called the Ordnung is central to their way of life, guiding how they interact with technology and each other.
With interviews and real-life footage, the film gives viewers a deeper understanding of the Amish and their unique way of life. The documentary also touches on challenges the Amish face in preserving their cultural identity amidst external influences.
Further details on "The Amish: How They Survive" can be found on IMDB.
7) Devil's Playground (2002)
"Devil's Playground," directed by Lucy Walker, is a compelling documentary that delves into the unique stages of Amish adolescence known as rumspringa. Released in 2002, this film offers a rare glimpse into the lives of Amish teenagers as they temporarily leave their communities to explore the outside world.
Rumspringa, translating to "running around" in Pennsylvania Dutch, is a pivotal time for Amish youth. At around 16, they are allowed to experience secular life and decide if they want to commit to the Amish way of living.
The documentary focuses on a few teenagers in LaGrange County, Indiana. They navigate modern temptations and freedoms, such as driving cars and using technology, all the while contemplating their cultural and religious futures.
The film is noted for its candid interviews and insights from both the teenagers and the adults in their communities. It sheds light on the internal struggles and societal pressures faced by these young individuals.
"Devil's Playground" not only documents their experiences but also questions the broader implications of such a transitional period. The audience gains a deeper understanding of the Amish lifestyle and the difficult choices these youths must make.
For more information, visit the Wikipedia page.
8) Amish Grace (2010)
"Amish Grace" (2010) is a poignant TV movie directed by Gregg Champion. It features Kimberly Williams-Paisley, Tammy Blanchard, and Fay Masterson in leading roles.
The film is based on the tragic shooting at a Pennsylvania Amish schoolhouse in 2006. Five children were killed, and five others were injured.
What sets this movie apart is its focus on the extraordinary forgiveness shown by the Amish community. Their compassion and willingness to forgive the shooter attracted worldwide media attention.
A major theme of the film is the stark contrast between the immense loss and the community's unwavering faith. It explores how the community reconciles their pain with their commitment to forgiveness.
For more information on "Amish Grace," visit its IMDb page.
9) Amish: A Secret Life (2012)
"Amish: A Secret Life" is a compelling documentary that offers a rare look into the daily lives of an Old Order Amish family in Pennsylvania. Directed by Lynn Alleway, the 2012 BBC film features David and Miriam Lapp and their children.
The documentary captures the family's adherence to Amish traditions, such as their abstinence from technology, including photography. This aspect of their lifestyle makes their agreement to be filmed intriguing.
David Lapp's work in a construction company and his balance of modern economic needs with strict religious principles highlight the compromises some Amish make. The portrayal provides a nuanced view of the Amish way of life, presenting both the warmth and the challenges they face.
For more information: IMDb
10) Amish Witches: The True Story of Holmes County (2016)
"Amish Witches: The True Story of Holmes County" is a 2016 horror film directed by Jake Wade Wall. Set in Holmes County, Ohio, the movie follows a reality TV crew documenting the lives of the Swartzentruber Amish, a highly traditional and isolated sect.
The production hits a chilling roadblock when a Brauchau, an Amish witch, dies. Unconsecrated funeral rites lead to bizarre and unexplained phenomena. A group of young Amish women then seeks the TV crew's assistance to document these eerie events.
This film combines elements of documentary and horror, offering a unique portrayal of the intersection between Amish culture and supernatural beliefs. It sheds light on the strict and mysterious world of the Swartzentruber Amish.
For more details, visit IMDb.
The Amish Way of Life
The Amish maintain a unique culture, characterized by strong community bonds and devout religious practices. Their way of life emphasizes simplicity and a rejection of many modern conveniences.
Community and Family Structures
Community is central to Amish life. They live in close-knit rural communities, often centered around a local church district. These districts govern the community and maintain order through "Ordnung," a set of unwritten rules.
Families are large, with an average of 7-10 children. Extended families often live nearby, strengthening ties and mutual support. Homes are multi-generational, with grandparents, parents, and children living together.
Work is divided along traditional gender lines. Men usually farm or work in trades, while women handle household duties. Children are taught practical skills from a young age, and education typically ends at the eighth grade.
Religious Beliefs and Practices
Religion guides every aspect of Amish life. They are Anabaptist Christians, emphasizing adult baptism and a personal commitment to faith. Worship services are held at homes, rotating among members' residences every two weeks.
The Amish reject worldly excess, adhering to plain dress and simple living. Technology is limited; for instance, they avoid cars, electricity, and telephones, favoring horse-drawn buggies and manual tools.
Church leaders, including bishops, ministers, and deacons, are chosen by lot, reflecting humility and divine selection. Religious instruction is integral, with daily family devotions led by the head of the household, ensuring that faith remains central from childhood onward.
Cultural and Historical Context
The cultural and historical roots of the Amish provide a foundation for their distinctive way of life. Their customs are deeply tied to their heritage, influencing their daily practices and community structure.
Origins and History of the Amish
The Amish originated from a group of Swiss and Alsatian Anabaptists in the late 17th century. Jacob Ammann, a key figure, led a split from the Mennonites due to differences in interpretations of religious practices and beliefs. This division solidified around 1693.
Anabaptists, from whom the Amish descended, insisted on adult baptism, a stance that led to persecution. Seeking religious freedom, many Amish emigrated to North America in the early 18th century. They settled mainly in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana, establishing communities aligned with their religious values.
Historical records show that the Amish have maintained their distinct identity through tight-knit community bonds and a steadfast adherence to traditional beliefs. The Ordnung, a set of unwritten rules, governs their daily life and religious practices, ensuring continuity from one generation to the next.
Cultural Customs and Traditions
Amish customs and traditions are rooted in their steadfast commitment to simplicity and humility. They avoid modern technologies, including electricity and automobiles, to focus on a life of piety and community.
Key customs include plain clothing, which reflects their values of modesty and separation from the world. Men typically wear broad-brimmed hats and beards after marriage, while women don bonnets and long dresses.
Community is central to their way of life. Rumspringa, a period during adolescence, allows youth to experience life outside the community before choosing baptism. Traditional crafts, like quilting and woodworking, are both practical and spiritually significant.
Their language, Pennsylvania Dutch, is a blend of German dialects, illustrating their European roots. The Amish worship in homes rather than churches, emphasizing fellowship and simplicity. Meals and gatherings often follow religious services, reinforcing community bonds.
